East Stirlingshire 2-3 Forfar Athletic *
| 08.05.2010 | Forfar Athletic | 2-2 | East Stirlingshire | |
| 05.05.2010 | East Stirlingshire | 0-1 | Forfar Athletic | |
Queen's Park FC 2-6 Arbroath FC *
| 08.05.2010 | Arbroath FC | 2-2 | Queen's Park FC | |
| 05.05.2010 | Queen's Park FC | 0-4 | Arbroath FC | |