*Montreal Impact 4-1 Charleston Battery
| 28.09.2009 | Charleston Battery | 1-2 | Montreal Impact | |
| 25.09.2009 | Montreal Impact | 2-0 | Charleston Battery | |
Rochester Rhinos 3-5 Puerto Rico Islanders *
| 28.09.2009 | Puerto Rico Islanders | 4-1 | Rochester Rhinos | |
| 25.09.2009 | Rochester Rhinos | 2-1 | Puerto Rico Islanders | |
*Vancouver WC 1-0 Carolina Railhawks
| 27.09.2009 | Carolina Railhawks | 0-0 | Vancouver WC | |
| 25.09.2009 | Vancouver WC | 1-0 | Carolina Railhawks | |