CAI de La Chorrera 0-4 New England Revs *
| 01.03.2024 | New England Revs | 3-0 | CAI de La Chorrera | |
| 22.02.2024 | CAI de La Chorrera | 0-1 | New England Revs | |
Cavalier FC 0-6 FC Cincinnati *
| 29.02.2024 | FC Cincinnati | 4-0 | Cavalier FC | |
| 23.02.2024 | Cavalier FC | 0-2 | FC Cincinnati | |
*CS Herediano 4-4 Deportivo Toluca
| 16.02.2024 | Deportivo Toluca | 2-3 | CS Herediano | |
| 08.02.2024 | CS Herediano | 1-2 | Deportivo Toluca | |
CSD Comunicaciones 1-7 CF Monterrey *
| 16.02.2024 | CF Monterrey | 3-0 | CSD Comunicaciones | |
| 07.02.2024 | CSD Comunicaciones | 1-4 | CF Monterrey | |
Forge FC 2-5 Guadalajara Chivas *
| 14.02.2024 | Guadalajara Chivas | 2-1 | Forge FC | |
| 08.02.2024 | Forge FC | 1-3 | Guadalajara Chivas | |
Moca FC 0-7 Nashville SC *
| 29.02.2024 | Nashville SC | 4-0 | Moca FC | |
| 23.02.2024 | Moca FC | 0-3 | Nashville SC | |
Cavalry FC 1-6 Orlando City SC *
| 28.02.2024 | Orlando City SC | 3-1 | Cavalry FC | |
| 22.02.2024 | Cavalry FC | 0-3 | Orlando City SC | |
Saprissa 5-6 Philadelphia Union *
| 28.02.2024 | Philadelphia Union | 3-3 AET | Saprissa | |
| 21.02.2024 | Saprissa | 2-3 | Philadelphia Union | |
Real Estelí 2-3 Club América *
| 15.02.2024 | Club América | 2-0 | Real Estelí | |
| 07.02.2024 | Real Estelí | 2-1 | Club América | |
St. Louis City SC 2-2 Houston Dynamo *
| 28.02.2024 | Houston Dynamo | 1-0 | St. Louis City SC | |
| 21.02.2024 | St. Louis City SC | 2-1 | Houston Dynamo | |
Vancouver WC 1-4 Tigres UANL *
| 15.02.2024 | Tigres UANL | 3-0 | Vancouver WC | |
| 08.02.2024 | Vancouver WC | 1-1 | Tigres UANL | |