Guadalajara Chivas 3-5 Club América *
| 14.03.2024 | Club América | 2-3 | Guadalajara Chivas | |
| 07.03.2024 | Guadalajara Chivas | 0-3 | Club América | |
*CS Herediano 3-1 SV Robinhood
| 13.03.2024 | SV Robinhood | 1-1 | CS Herediano | |
| 05.03.2024 | CS Herediano | 2-0 | SV Robinhood | |
FC Cincinnati 1-3 CF Monterrey *
| 15.03.2024 | CF Monterrey | 2-1 | FC Cincinnati | |
| 08.03.2024 | FC Cincinnati | 0-1 | CF Monterrey | |
Houston Dynamo 1-2 Columbus Crew *
| 12.03.2024 | Columbus Crew | 1-1 | Houston Dynamo | |
| 07.03.2024 | Houston Dynamo | 0-1 | Columbus Crew | |
Nashville SC 3-5 Inter Miami CF *
| 14.03.2024 | Inter Miami CF | 3-1 | Nashville SC | |
| 08.03.2024 | Nashville SC | 2-2 | Inter Miami CF | |
*New England Revs 5-1 LD Alajuelense
| 15.03.2024 | LD Alajuelense | 1-1 | New England Revs | |
| 07.03.2024 | New England Revs | 4-0 | LD Alajuelense | |
Orlando City SC 2-4 Tigres UANL *
| 13.03.2024 | Tigres UANL | 4-2 | Orlando City SC | |
| 06.03.2024 | Orlando City SC | 0-0 | Tigres UANL | |
Philadelphia Union 0-6 Pachuca CF *
| 13.03.2024 | Pachuca CF | 6-0 | Philadelphia Union | |
| 06.03.2024 | Philadelphia Union | 0-0 | Pachuca CF | |