*Cruz Azul 2-0 UNAM Pumas
| 05.03.2009 | UNAM Pumas | 0-1 | Cruz Azul | |
| 26.02.2009 | Cruz Azul | 1-0 | UNAM Pumas | |
Houston Dynamo 1-4 Atlante FC *
| 04.03.2009 | Atlante FC | 3-0 | Houston Dynamo | |
| 25.02.2009 | Houston Dynamo | 1-1 | Atlante FC | |
Montreal Impact 4-5 Santos Laguna *
| 06.03.2009 | Santos Laguna | 5-2 | Montreal Impact | |
| 26.02.2009 | Montreal Impact | 2-0 | Santos Laguna | |
*Puerto Rico Islanders 3-1 CD Marathón
| 05.03.2009 | CD Marathón | 0-1 | Puerto Rico Islanders | |
| 27.02.2009 | Puerto Rico Islanders | 2-1 | CD Marathón | |