AFC Ajax 0-4 Aston Villa *
| 14.03.2024 | Aston Villa | 4-0 | AFC Ajax | |
| 07.03.2024 | AFC Ajax | 0-0 | Aston Villa | |
Molde FK 2-4 Club Brugge *
| 14.03.2024 | Club Brugge | 3-0 | Molde FK | |
| 07.03.2024 | Molde FK | 2-1 | Club Brugge | |
Maccabi Haifa 4-5 Fiorentina *
| 14.03.2024 | Fiorentina | 1-1 | Maccabi Haifa | |
| 07.03.2024 | Maccabi Haifa | 3-4 | Fiorentina | |
*Olympiakos Pireus 7-5 Maccabi Tel Aviv
| 14.03.2024 | Maccabi Tel Aviv | 1-6 AET | Olympiakos Pireus | |
| 07.03.2024 | Olympiakos Pireus | 1-4 | Maccabi Tel Aviv | |
Dinamo Zagreb 3-5 PAOK Salonica *
| 14.03.2024 | PAOK Salonica | 5-1 | Dinamo Zagreb | |
| 07.03.2024 | Dinamo Zagreb | 2-0 | PAOK Salonica | |
Servette FC 0-0 Viktoria Plzen *
| 14.03.2024 | Viktoria Plzen | 0-0/p.3-1 | Servette FC | |
| 07.03.2024 | Servette FC | 0-0 | Viktoria Plzen | |
Sturm Graz 1-4 Lille OSC *
| 14.03.2024 | Lille OSC | 1-1 | Sturm Graz | |
| 07.03.2024 | Sturm Graz | 0-3 | Lille OSC | |
Union Saint-Gilloise 1-3 Fenerbahçe SK *
| 14.03.2024 | Fenerbahçe SK | 0-1 | Union Saint-Gilloise | |
| 07.03.2024 | Union Saint-Gilloise | 0-3 | Fenerbahçe SK | |