AE Larisa 1-5 Atromitos FC *
| 16.01.2024 | Atromitos FC | 4-0 | AE Larisa | |
| 06.12.2023 | AE Larisa | 1-1 | Atromitos FC | |
AEK Athens 1-1 Aris Salonica *
| 17.01.2024 | Aris Salonica | 1-1/p.4-2 | AEK Athens | |
| 10.01.2024 | AEK Athens | 0-0 | Aris Salonica | |
Asteras Tripoli 1-3 Panserraikos *
| 10.01.2024 | Panserraikos | 1-1 | Asteras Tripoli | |
| 05.12.2023 | Asteras Tripoli | 0-2 | Panserraikos | |
Levadiakos 1-2 Niki Volos *
| 18.01.2024 | Niki Volos | 1-0 | Levadiakos | |
| 07.12.2023 | Levadiakos | 1-1 | Niki Volos | |
*OFI Creta 4-2 Kifisia FC
| 17.01.2024 | Kifisia FC | 1-1 | OFI Creta | |
| 06.12.2023 | OFI Creta | 3-1 | Kifisia FC | |
*Panathinaikos 1-1 Olympiakos Pireus
| 17.01.2024 | Olympiakos Pireus | 0-0/p.6-7 | Panathinaikos | |
| 10.01.2024 | Panathinaikos | 1-1 | Olympiakos Pireus | |
*Panetolikos 5-4 Athens Kallithea
| 17.01.2024 | Athens Kallithea | 2-2 | Panetolikos | |
| 05.12.2023 | Panetolikos | 3-2 | Athens Kallithea | |
*PAOK Salonica 3-0 Volos NFC
| 10.01.2024 | Volos NFC | 0-2 | PAOK Salonica | |
| 07.12.2023 | PAOK Salonica | 1-0 | Volos NFC | |