*Columbus Crew 8-6 Atlanta United
| 13.11.2023 | Columbus Crew | 4-2 | Atlanta United | |
| 08.11.2023 | Atlanta United | 4-2 | Columbus Crew | |
| 02.11.2023 | Columbus Crew | 2-0 | Atlanta United | |
*FC Cincinnati 4-1 New York Red Bulls
| 05.11.2023 | New York Red Bulls | 1-1/p.7-8 | FC Cincinnati | |
| 30.10.2023 | FC Cincinnati | 3-0 | New York Red Bulls | |
*Houston Dynamo 4-3 Real Salt Lake
| 12.11.2023 | Houston Dynamo | 1-1/p.4-3 | Real Salt Lake | |
| 07.11.2023 | Real Salt Lake | 1-1/p.5-4 | Houston Dynamo | |
| 29.10.2023 | Houston Dynamo | 2-1 | Real Salt Lake | |
*Orlando City SC 2-0 Nashville SC
| 08.11.2023 | Nashville SC | 0-1 | Orlando City SC | |
| 31.10.2023 | Orlando City SC | 1-0 | Nashville SC | |
*Philadelphia Union 4-1 New England Revs
| 09.11.2023 | New England Revs | 0-1 | Philadelphia Union | |
| 28.10.2023 | Philadelphia Union | 3-1 | New England Revs | |
*Seattle Sounders 4-3 FC Dallas
| 11.11.2023 | Seattle Sounders | 1-0 | FC Dallas | |
| 05.11.2023 | FC Dallas | 3-1 | Seattle Sounders | |
| 31.10.2023 | Seattle Sounders | 2-0 | FC Dallas | |
St. Louis City SC 2-6 Sporting Kansas City *
| 05.11.2023 | Sporting Kansas City | 2-1 | St. Louis City SC | |
| 30.10.2023 | St. Louis City SC | 1-4 | Sporting Kansas City | |
*Los Angeles FC 6-2 Vancouver WC
| 06.11.2023 | Vancouver WC | 0-1 | Los Angeles FC | |
| 29.10.2023 | Los Angeles FC | 5-2 | Vancouver WC | |